The Unique Nature of the Home Workplace

Hiring a Migrant Domestic Worker (MDW) is distinct from any corporate hiring decision. You aren't just managing an employee; you are managing a relationship within your private sanctuary.

At GentleHelp, we understand the complexity of this dynamic. In Singapore, where space is premium and lives are busy, the employer-helper relationship is intense. It is rarely a simple case of a "bad employer" or a "bad helper." More often, friction arises from mismatched expectations, cultural differences, and communication gaps.

When you feel things aren't working, it is essential to pause and evaluate the situation objectively before making a decision. Is this a performance issue, a training gap, or a cultural misunderstanding?

Phase 1: The Relationship "Health Check"

Before jumping to conclusions about your helper's attitude, it is helpful to break down her performance into three objective categories. This helps separate emotion from fact.

1. Proficiency (The Skills)

• The Question: Can she physically perform the tasks?
• The Reality Check: Every Singaporean household is different. A helper who was excellent at general cleaning for a previous employer might struggle with your specific requirements for cooking local dishes or handling specific appliances.
• The Evaluation: Are the mistakes due to carelessness, or simply a lack of specific training on your preferences?

2. Proactivity (The Initiative)

• The Question: Does she anticipate needs, or does she wait for instructions?
• The Cultural Context: This is the most common source of frustration for Singapore employers who value efficiency. However, in many rural cultures across Indonesia, Myanmar, or the Philippines, waiting for instructions is a sign of respect, whereas acting without permission can be seen as overstepping boundaries.
• The Evaluation: Is she "lazy," or is she afraid of making a mistake by acting without your permission?

3. Personality (The Fit)

• The Question: How does the daily interaction feel?
• The Reality Check: You are sharing a living space 24/7. Compatibility matters. Some employers prefer a helper who is chatty and warm with the kids; others prefer someone quiet who focuses on chores.
• The Evaluation: Is the friction caused by "attitude," or simply a difference in communication styles?

Phase 2: Diagnosis & Solutions

Once you have identified the root cause using the check above, you can determine the right path forward.

Scenario A: The Learning Curve (Skill Gap)

The Situation: She is willing, polite, and tries hard, but the outcome isn't meeting your standards (e.g., food is too salty, clothes are shrunk, floors are still sticky).The GentleHelp Insight: This is the most solvable scenario. A willing attitude is the hardest trait to find; skills can be taught.Next Steps:

• Show, Don’t Just Tell: Language barriers (especially with new transfers or fresh helpers) often make verbal instructions ineffective. Demonstrate the task exactly how you want it done.
• Use Visuals: Photos of a "perfectly made bed" or a WhatsApp video of how to use the washing machine are often more effective than repeated verbal corrections.
• Patience: Remember she is adapting to a high-tech, fast-paced Singapore lifestyle which may be very different from her village.

Scenario B: The Cultural Disconnect (Communication Gap)

The Situation: You feel she is ignoring you or giving you "attitude." Perhaps she smiles when you are correcting her (which is often a cultural reaction to embarrassment, not defiance), or she says "Yes" but doesn't do the task (which often means "I hear you," not "I understand").The GentleHelp Insight: This is usually a misunderstanding, not malice.

‍Next Steps:

• The "Teach-Back" Method: After giving an instruction, ask her gently, "Can you show me how you are going to do that?" to ensure understanding.
• Reset Expectations: Sit down for a calm chat. Explain that in your home, asking questions is encouraged and saying "I don't understand" is better than guessing.

Scenario C: The Alignment Failure (Fit or Trust Issues)

The Situation: Despite clear communication and training, there is consistent dishonesty, safety negligence (leaving children unsupervised), or a complete clash in personality that is causing stress for the whole family.The GentleHelp Insight: Not every match is meant to be. Sometimes, a helper who struggles in one family thrives in another with different needs.

‍Next Steps:

• Safety First: If safety is compromised, immediate action is required.
• Call GentleHelp for Mediation: Before deciding to transfer, let us speak to her. Sometimes, a helper is facing personal issues (like debt or family illness back home) that are affecting her work. We can uncover these issues in her native language.

How to Have a Constructive Discussion

Conflict resolution is our expertise. If you need to address performance, follow these rules to keep it fair and constructive:

1. Strike While the Iron is Cold: Never correct a helper when you are angry. Wait until you are calm.
2. Fact, Not Emotion:
   • Avoid: "You are so lazy."
   • Try: "I noticed the floor was not mopped yesterday and today."
3. Ask, Don't Accuse: Ask, "Is there a reason the floor wasn't mopped?" Sometimes the answer is valid (e.g., "The baby was crying all afternoon").
4. Document Everything: Keep a simple notebook of incidents. This provides clarity for you, and helps us assist you better if MOM intervention or a transfer becomes necessary.

When to Call gentleHelp

You do not have to manage this relationship alone. As your agency, we are here to support both the employer and the helper to ensure a sustainable employment period.

Reach out to us if:

• You have tried correcting the same mistake 3 times with no change.
• Communication has broken down and you need a neutral third party to translate or mediate.
• You are unsure if a behavior is a cultural misunderstanding or a serious concern.

We can arrange a counseling session for your helper at our office, or simply provide you with advice on how to navigate the specific situation.

Managing a household is hard work. Let us help you make it gentle.

‍